Culture and Controversy

Cindy 14Today we have a Cindy Williams joining us, author of novel The Pounamu Prophecy, which was released October last year by Rhiza Press. (Which also happens to be my publisher, too. 🙂 ) She’s going to share some insights about her novel, so let’s welcome her. Thanks, Cindy.


‘So tell me about this controversial book you have written,’ the announcer asked me during a recent radio interview. I would have stuttered in shock if I had not spent the morning at a cafe with the lovely Iola Goulton discussing this very issue!

I don’t do controversy. I am exhausted by my son’s love of ‘debating’ which I see as arguing; I wither in the face of disputes about politics and religion; I almost always stay silent in the face of dogmatic opinions about nutriton that, as a dietitian, I know are misinformed.

The first hint that The Pounamu Prophecy might be controversial pounamuprophecymedwas when a member of my mother’s book group commented that I was ‘brave’ to write such a book. What was brave about telling a story about a piece of New Zealand’s history that few people knew, I wondered. It wasn’t until I recently travelled to New Zealand to do a few author talks that I saw the discomfort of some people as I spoke of the injustices that the Ngati Whatua tribe suffered over the past 100 years.

‘Don’t talk too much about that stuff, Cindy,’ advised my mother. ‘The book says it well. Let it speak, not you.’ It was wise advice. I adjusted my talk and encouraged the audience that New Zealand, despite its past failings, is an example to the world of how two cultures can live well together and celebrate the best of both.

History is subjective, seen through the eyes and felt through the heart of whoever was there. For this story I had the privilege of interviewing an elder of the Ngati Whatua tribe. He was eight years old when the government burnt down his village to ‘tidy it up’ for Queen Elizabeth’s visit the following year. There were tears in his eyes as he recounted what had happened. It was a perspective few people, including myself, had heard. It was a story worth telling.

‘If one of our people had written this, many would dismiss it as just another sob story, ‘ he said. ‘But when a Pakeha (non-Maori) writes it, it has credibility.’

IMG_2035So here was the reason God had arranged for me, a Pakeha girl married into a Maori family, to write it. A purely Maori perspective might stir up resentment and anger, slashing open old wounds with no remedy or hope of reconciliation. A purely Pakeha perspective might defend itself with stories of less than honorable actions of some Maori. (I remember hiding every lunchtime for a year in the school toilets terrified of the big Maori girls who bullied me. A few years later when we moved to the mostly Maori part of town behind the pub, they would offer me cigarettes on the school bus and I knew I was ‘okay’!)

I believe, as followers of Jesus and if we are open to his leading, God uses our background, our experiences, our strengths and our weaknesses to write the stories he knows will bless others. I have realised that the novel I am currently writing will be even more controversial than the last and it is driving me to my knees in prayer every time I write. Isn’t that what He wants? For when I am weak, then I am strong. (2 Cor 12:10)

Cindy Williams lives in Sydney with her husband and teenage son. As a child growing up in a culturally rich part of New Zealand she enjoyed writing, not copious screeds, but short intense pieces that brought tears to her eyes and made people think. She marvelled at the power of words to inspire far beyond the intentions of the author. Then she became a dietitian – all science and seriously researched facts. She completed a Master of Public Health and a Graduate Diploma in Communication and spent many years encouraging and inspiring people to live a healthy life. She writes a nutrition blog and is working on her second novel, set in first century Israel. She teaches scripture in schools, and swim and cycles. She is also studying for a Diploma of Theology and trying to improve her abysmal French!

You can contact Cindy via her website or cindy[at]


8 thoughts on “Culture and Controversy

  1. I really enjoyed the Pounamu Prophecy. My husband and I visited New Zealand last year which helped me appreciate the book.

    While we were in NZ we did a number of day trips with different tour companies. Each time we were given a brief history of New Zealand and it was interesting to note the different perspectives of the tour guides. There was the English tour guide who failed to mention any of the atrocities committed by the white settlers. There was the Maori guide who acknowledged the injustices which had taken place but was appreciative of the good things English culture had brought like medicine and education. Then there was the Maori guide who only mentioned the injustices of the English and didn’t acknowledge any of the benefits. Taken together I felt like we ended up with a more complete history. And I agree that NZ is a great example of how two cultures can live together.

    • Hi Susan,
      There are certainly different attitudes to NZ’s cultural history. I like the sound of your first Maori guide. This is the perspective my father-in-law has and it is wonderful.

  2. Great to hear that you’ve been able to get your story out there, Cindy, in spite of the fact that it’s ‘controversial’. I enjoyed it immensely when I was editing it and I’m glad to hear it’s generating discussion.

    • Thanks, Lynne. Your editing was so wonderful in weeding out all the cringy bits!! As for the controversy: all publicity is good publicity, so they say!!

  3. Sounds like an interesting book Cindy. A little controversy can be good in getting people talking about an issue. Good on you for being brave enough to tell the story God laid on your heart. I’m sure it will resonate with a lot of people and bring healing.

  4. Thanks for the interview Cindy and Adele – I enjoyed reading The Pounamu Prophecy – especially for how it revealed an part of Maori & New Zealand history I wasn’t aware of as an Aussie. I love that you were able to bring both Pakeha and Maori perspectives.

Comments are closed.